How Can We Regain Control of Our News? A Look Back at the Expert Sessions
Twelve experts—ranging from professors to journalists—spent three sessions exploring the ways in which we risk losing control over our news. The result is a collection of 21 media issues that deserve attention in the coming years. The experts are critical of the power of tech platforms and the consequences of AI, but they also warn that those who paint too bleak a picture of the media landscape are missing out on opportunities.
In the first two sessions, we worked together to identify the most important developments, consequences, and dilemmas. From these, we selected the media issues. In the third session, we presented these again to the expert panel with the question: Which issues are most important for the Great Media Debate? This resulted in 21 issues, which you can read via this link.
We combined the 21 issues with the 8 issues that emerged from the citizen panel into 7 statements, which we then presented to NU.nl readers via the NUjij interactive platform.
Opportunities and Risks
Trust in traditional news media is declining, but by international standards, the Netherlands is still doing well. This is evident from the Dutch edition of the Digital News Report, published by the Netherlands Media Authority. Compared to our European neighbors, trust here is fairly high. Trust in news from social media, however, is significantly lower. According to the twelve experts, this distinction is important. Those who paint too bleak a picture of the media landscape run the risk of overlooking opportunities.
Experts believe that change in the media landscape isn’t necessarily a bad thing. For example, anyone can create media these days, which promotes a diversity of voices. People can also choose for themselves what information they want to consume. One of the experts refers to this as the “democratization” of the media landscape. In the past, people had to hope that the newspaper would cover an Ajax game; today, the club has its own app and social media accounts with millions of followers.
In addition to opportunities, the experts also identify risks. Smaller content creators are not bound by the same journalistic codes of ethics as traditional media, nor are they always accountable for the quality of their content. Platforms use opaque algorithms that often fuel polarization and mistrust. With chatbots, it’s almost impossible to understand how responses are generated or why certain users receive specific answers. This can undermine the shared factual foundation of our public debate. Furthermore, these systems can produce inaccurate results and are also susceptible to manipulation.



The Power of Big Tech
According to experts, the power and influence of global tech companies go hand in hand with a lack of accountability. Meta, X, Alphabet, and Bytedance take little or no responsibility for the content they distribute or for the addictive techniques they employ. Moreover, the power of these platforms extends beyond the media landscape alone: the influence of major tech companies reaches into the political arena, where these entities are increasingly helping to determine which rules apply.
How social media platforms’ algorithms work is opaque. This lack of transparency affects the behavior of content creators. It is unclear which content is being shadowbanned. by the platforms’ algorithms or content moderation. That is why some creators self-censor, for fear that their accounts will be restricted or deleted. As a result, there is an invisible filter over social media content, much to the surprise of experts from traditional media.
Algorithms aren’t new, an expert emphasized, but they do play an increasingly important role in the selection, organization, and dissemination of information. Extensive personalization is commercially attractive: platforms know exactly which product, service, or news suits you based on your viewing and search behavior. This allows social media channels to sell highly targeted ads with a specific reach. Because platforms offer free content, people are less willing to pay for journalism.
According to the experts, it is important that social media algorithms become transparent, so that consumers once again understand why they are shown certain content—or not. That is not the case right now, and this gives big tech companies free rein: platform owners manipulate algorithms as they see fit, without being held accountable. As a result, both policymakers and the public are losing control over the flow of information.
The Rise of AI
According to experts, the rise of AI has two sides. The good news: information is more accessible than ever and easier to disseminate. AI also makes it easier and faster to delve deeper into a topic: people can quickly catch up on information they’ve missed, and journalistic workflows can be organized more efficiently.
On the other hand, experts note that AI undermines trust in the authenticity of images and videos. The ease with which AI can create fake images that are indistinguishable—or nearly indistinguishable—from the real thing is alarming and, understandably, makes people wary. In addition, experts fear cognitive decline if skills such as listening, reading, and thinking are practiced less frequently as a result of AI. Furthermore, inequality may arise between people who effectively harness AI to their advantage—for example, to learn more quickly—and those who are primarily disadvantaged by it.

Journalism
According to experts, the shifts in the information society driven by social media and AI tools are affecting the very core of the journalism profession. People expect more news—and faster. Whereas editorial staff used to naturally determine what constituted news, journalists must now navigate a world where anyone can be a content creator and information is abundantly available. “We no longer just consume media—we live in it,” said one expert. This is also changing the role of journalists: “Has reliable information become a public utility?” one expert wondered.
One of the experts spoke about a media outlet with a much smaller budget than the major public broadcasters, which—thanks to smart use of social media and in-depth background stories—still has a wider reach than ever before. So large, in fact, that traditional media outlets are now asking for the secret to its success. This is a striking paradox: the very same platforms that compete with traditional journalism for reach and advertising revenue also offer those same media outlets an opportunity to reach a larger audience.
Impact on Society
What do these developments mean for society? People are looking for guidance amid the abundance of information, according to the exploratory qualitative study by Ipsos I&O commissioned by the Democracy and Media Foundation and De Argumentenfabriek. People with relatively little trust in institutions follow what might be called a “news diet”: they consciously consume very little news and rely primarily on their social circles to ensure that important news reaches them. The idea that “if it’s important, I’ll hear about it anyway” is gaining ground.
People with a high level of trust do the opposite: they consult multiple news sources side by side and try to draw their own conclusions from them. This difference in approach sometimes leads to social awkwardness: what do you do when it turns out that your neighbor reads news sources that are very different from yours? Participants in the Ipsos I&O survey from both sides saw this as a sensitive issue.
The phenomenon of fragmentation in the media landscape and media consumption raises a fundamental question, which the experts referred to as the problem of “intersubjective truth-finding”: if everyone has their own stream of information, how can we still make collective decisions about the organization of society?
What now?
In the spring of 2027, we’ll be heading out across the country. We’ll be organizing meetups in various locations to discuss the future of our information services. Stay up to date on these events via the update email.
News and articles


